Publication time reported by BabyLoveGrowth, shown in Mountain time. This is not an independently measured first appearance on this website.

Medicare Broker Cost: What You Pay (and Who Does)

A licensed Medicare broker costs you nothing. Medicare.gov says an agent or broker cannot charge you an enrollment fee, and the insurance company whose plan you pick pays the broker’s commission. At Simply Insurance, our guidance on Medicare Advantage, Medigap and Part D plans comes at no direct cost to you. Below is how the money moves, how large the commissions are, and what to ask so you know the advice is working for you.
Simplyinsuranceforyousimplyinsuranceforyou.comChoose Medicare Plans With ConfidenceSimply Insurance offers personalized, independent guidance to compare Medicare options, with ongoing support for claims and annual reviews.VisitTL;DR
- You pay no fee to a licensed Medicare broker. Federal marketing rules bar an enrollment fee, and carriers pay the commission.
- Your plan premium is set by the plan, not by how you enroll, so a broker does not add to what you pay for the same plan.
- Federal rules cap what insurers can pay agents for Medicare Advantage and Part D. Medigap commissions follow state law and are usually a percentage of premium.
- Ask any broker how they are paid, which carriers they represent, and whether they help after you enroll.
- Original Medicare (Parts A and B) pays no commissions. Brokers sell private plans that work alongside it.
Table of Contents
- Do you have to pay for a Medicare broker?
- Who pays Medicare brokers?
- Is it more expensive to go through a broker?
- How much commission do Medicare agents earn?
- What to ask before you work with a broker
- Timing: when a broker helps most
- What a broker does for you at Simply Insurance
- Where we fit in
- Our view: free does not mean careless
- FAQ
- Sources
Do you have to pay for a Medicare broker?
No. During a meeting about Medicare plans, an agent or broker cannot charge an enrollment fee, push you toward a particular plan, pressure you to join, or ask you to sign an enrollment form before you are ready. The National Council on Aging adds that you should not be charged for a consultation and have no obligation to buy from a broker you meet with.
What a broker sells matters here. Brokers work with private Medicare plans: Medicare Advantage, Medigap (also called Medicare Supplement) and standalone Part D drug plans. They do not sell Original Medicare, which you sign up for through the Social Security Administration. So a broker never charges you to enroll in Parts A and B, and you would not pay anyone for that.
If someone asks you for an upfront fee for help choosing or enrolling in one of these plans, that is a reason to stop and ask questions. The marketing rules say agents must be licensed by your state. In Colorado, you can verify an agent’s license through the Division of Insurance before you sit down with anyone.

Who pays Medicare brokers?
The insurance companies pay. When you enroll in a plan through a broker, the carrier pays the broker a commission for that enrollment. CMS explains that agents generally receive an initial payment in the first year of a policy, or when you change to a different type of plan. They receive half as much in later years if you stay enrolled or switch to a similar type of plan.
Two plain terms help here:
- Initial enrollment: you are new to Medicare, or you move to a different type of plan, for example from a Medigap policy to a Medicare Advantage plan.
- Renewal: you keep the same plan, or switch to a plan of the same type.
That renewal payment is why a broker can help you year after year without billing you. It is also why we run annual reviews: a plan that fit last year may not cover your drugs, doctors or budget this year.
Is it more expensive to go through a broker?
Not for the same plan. A plan’s premium is filed by the insurer and applies to everyone who buys it. A broker does not add a markup on top. The commission is the carrier’s cost of doing business, and it is part of the carrier’s overall pricing whether you enroll through a broker, by phone or on a website.
The practical difference is the help. Comparing plans on your own means checking each plan’s premium, deductible, drug list, provider network and out-of-pocket maximum. A broker does that comparison across carriers and enrolls you in the plan you choose. A few carriers offer small discounts for certain Medigap enrollments, such as paying by bank draft or having a household member on the same plan. A broker can check those for you as part of quoting.
Your real costs come from the plan itself, not the broker:
What you pay Who it goes to Does a broker change it? Broker fee No one. There is none. No Plan premium The insurer (or Medicare for Parts A and B) No, same plan, same premium Deductibles, copays, coinsurance The provider or plan, depending on coverage No, but the plan you choose sets them Part B premium Medicare NoThe choice of plan is the part that moves your yearly costs. For Colorado figures, our guide to Medicare costs in Colorado walks through what people typically pay, and the Medicare Cost Calculator lets you put in your own situation.
It also helps to know how any provider explains billing before you commit to a plan. Medical practices, for example, publish pages on insurance billing and payment options so patients can see what their insurance covers and what they pay themselves. Your plan’s copays and coinsurance are the equivalent on the Medicare side, and a broker can show you how they compare before you enroll.
How much commission do Medicare agents earn?
Commission amounts are set by rules, not by negotiation with you, and they are the same no matter which broker you use. They vary by plan type, state and whether it is an initial or renewal enrollment.
Medicare Advantage and Part D
For contract year 2025, MedPAC reports national maximums of $626 for an initial Medicare Advantage enrollment and $313 for a renewal, and $109 initial and $55 renewal for standalone Part D. For contract year 2026, a compensation memo citing the federal regulations lists national maximums of $694 initial and $347 renewal for Medicare Advantage, and $114 initial and $57 renewal for Part D. A few areas have higher or lower Medicare Advantage figures, such as California at $864 initial.

These amounts are paid by the plan to the agent. They are not added to your premium. CMS published the rule that sets this structure in its Contract Year 2025 final rule, which set a clear, fixed amount agents can be paid regardless of the plan they enroll you in, and raised the national initial amount by $100.
One detail that affects what an agent earns: under 42 CFR 422.2274, when you enroll in a Medicare Advantage plan that includes drug coverage, the plan may pay only the Medicare Advantage compensation, not a separate Part D amount on top.
Medigap
Medigap commissions are governed by state law rather than the federal caps. MedPAC notes they are typically about 20% of the premium in the first year and about 10% in later years. The Medicare Rights Center puts the national average at $521 initially and $260 at renewal. Again, these come out of the insurer’s side of the premium. The same Medigap plan from the same carrier costs the same whether or not you use a broker.
Why the rules look the way they do
CMS says the Medicare statute requires compensation to create incentives for agents to enroll people in the plan that best meets their needs. That is the reason for fixed amounts. Insurers can also pay agents for other services, such as training, administrative support and marketing, as described in MedPAC’s briefing. The Medicare Rights Center reports that litigation halted CMS’s attempt to limit administrative payments, so those payments continue. This is why the questions in the next section are worth asking of any broker.
What to ask before you work with a broker
A free service still has to be a good one. The National Council on Aging suggests asking how a broker is paid and whether they support you beyond the first enrollment, since some focus only on new sign-ups. Use this list:
- Are you licensed in Colorado? The marketing rules require state licensing, and plans must tell the state which agents sell their plans. Federal rules also require agents to be trained and tested each year, and to document a Scope of Appointment, your agreement on which plan types you will discuss, before a personal meeting.
- Which carriers do you represent? An independent broker compares across several carriers. Our carriers page lists the ones we represent.
- How are you paid? Expect the answer: by carriers, through commission, at no charge to you.
- Will you help after I enroll? Claims questions, drug list changes and yearly plan reviews are where much of the value is.
- Will you put the comparison in writing? Premiums, deductibles, drug costs and networks side by side are easier to judge than a verbal summary.
You also do not have to enroll the day you meet. You can take the comparison home, talk it over with family and decide later within your enrollment window.
Timing: when a broker helps most
Your first chance to enroll is the seven-month Initial Enrollment Period around your 65th birthday. Choices made then, particularly Part B and whether you pair Original Medicare with a Medigap plan or choose Medicare Advantage, shape your costs for years. Missing Part B can bring a late penalty, which our guide on Part B enrollment explains. A 12-month checklist before turning 65 shows when to start the conversation, and the enrollment timeline maps the windows.
After that, the fall Annual Enrollment Period is when most people review their coverage. It runs on the same recurring schedule each year, so check Medicare.gov for the exact current dates. Because renewal compensation is built into the system, the review itself carries no charge from us.
What a broker does for you at Simply Insurance
We are an independent brokerage serving Castle Pines and the rest of Colorado. We help you compare Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement and Part D plans, and we also help with individual and family health insurance, dental and supplemental plans. Our support continues beyond enrollment, through claims help and annual reviews.
If you are choosing between the two main paths, start with Medicare Advantage versus Medigap. It shows how the premium, network and out-of-pocket tradeoffs differ, which matters far more to your wallet than any broker fee, because there is none.
Where we fit in
We get paid by carriers when you enroll, with no direct cost to you. That means our job is to show you plans that fit your doctors, your prescriptions and your budget, and to be around when you need us.
If you live in the Denver area, our pages for a Medicare broker in Denver and a Medicare broker in Centennial describe how we work locally.
Ready to compare? Our Medicare planning and plan quotes cover Medicare Advantage consultations, Plan G and Plan N quotes, annual enrollment reviews and help with appeals and grievances. You can also start from our home page.

Our view: free does not mean careless
Most people who call us ask the same thing first: what is this going to cost me? The answer is nothing, and we say so before we ask a single question about your health.
What we think matters more is what you get for that nothing. The plan you pick sets your yearly costs, not the broker. A good broker should know which doctors and prescriptions you rely on, compare more than one carrier, and explain the tradeoff between a lower premium and a higher out-of-pocket maximum in plain words.
We also think enrollment day is the start, not the finish. Plans change their drug lists, networks and costs every year. We built our service around annual reviews, claims help and appeals support because that is when people most need a person who already knows their file.
If you take only one thing from this article, let it be this: ask every broker how they are paid, whether they are licensed in Colorado and whether they will still be there next October. We are happy to answer all three.
Zach
FAQ
Are Medicare brokers really free?
Yes, to you. Federal marketing rules say an agent or broker cannot charge an enrollment fee, and the insurance carrier pays the commission. Your premium for a given plan is the same however you enroll.
Who pays Medicare brokers?
The insurance companies pay them. CMS describes an initial payment in the first year and a smaller payment in later years if you stay enrolled or make a like-for-like change. Original Medicare itself pays no commissions.
Do brokers get paid more for certain plans?
Federal rules set maximum amounts for Medicare Advantage and Part D, and they apply regardless of which plan within that type the agent enrolls you in. Carriers may also pay for other services, such as training or administration, which is why it is fair to ask any broker how they are paid and which carriers they compare.
Can I switch plans later, and does the broker charge for that?
You can review your coverage each fall during the Annual Enrollment Period and make changes then. There is no broker fee for the review. Our annual reviews are part of the service, so you can check your plan against next year’s costs, drug list and doctors.
How do I check that a broker is legitimate?
Ask for their name and license number, then look them up through the Colorado Division of Insurance license lookup. The Medicare marketing rules require agents to be licensed by your state.
Sources
- Marketing rules for Medicare health & drug plans | Medicare.gov
- What to Expect When Discussing Medicare With a Broker | National Council on Aging
- Agent Broker Compensation | CMS
- Background: Medicare insurance agents | MedPAC, March 2025
- Agent compensation memo, contract year 2026
- Contract Year 2025 Medicare Advantage and Part D Final Rule | CMS
- 42 CFR 422.2274 | eCFR
- Medicare Advantage Marketing, Brokers, and Agents | Medicare Rights Center
- Consumer Protection | Colorado Division of Insurance
