Publication time reported by BabyLoveGrowth, shown in Mountain time. This is not an independently measured first appearance on this website.

What a Medicare Broker Does and How They Get Paid

A Medicare broker is a licensed professional who helps you compare private Medicare plans, enroll in the one that fits your doctors, drugs and budget, and stay covered as plans change. You do not pay the broker. The insurance company pays a commission when you enroll. If you are turning 65 or confused by Medicare’s many parts, an independent broker who works with several carriers and stays with you after you enroll is often the simplest route to a good decision. That is how we work at Simply Insurance for clients in Castle Pines and across Colorado.
SimplyinsuranceforyouGet Clear Guidance on Medicare OptionsSimply Insurance offers personalized, independent guidance to compare Medicare plans, with ongoing support during enrollment and beyond.VisitTL;DR
- A broker compares plans, checks your doctors, pharmacy and prescriptions against each one, and handles enrollment paperwork.
- You pay nothing to the broker. Insurers pay commissions, and federal rules limit what they can pay for Medicare Advantage and Part D.
- “Agent” and “broker” are often used interchangeably. The difference that matters to you is whether the person can show you plans from many carriers.
- Free, unbiased counseling also exists through Colorado’s state health insurance program, so you have choices in how you get help.
- The best brokers stay involved after enrollment: claims questions, appeals and a yearly plan review.
Table of Contents
- What a Medicare broker actually does
- Medicare broker vs. agent: does the difference matter?
- Are Medicare brokers free?
- What a broker cannot do
- Do you need a Medicare broker?
- A worked example: turning 65 in Castle Pines
- Our point of view
- How we help at Simply Insurance
- FAQ
- Sources
What a Medicare broker actually does
Traditional Medicare (Parts A and B) is run by the federal government. The private options around it are where most people get stuck: Medicare Advantage (Part C), Medicare Supplement (Medigap) and stand-alone Part D drug plans. These are sold by private insurers, and the choices change every year. A broker is the licensed person who sorts through them with you.
In practice the work looks like this:
- Understanding your situation. Your health, your budget, the doctors you want to keep, the pharmacy you use and the medications you take.
- Narrowing the plan type. Do you want the flexibility of Original Medicare with a Medigap plan, or an all-in-one Medicare Advantage plan with a network?
- Checking the details. Is each of your doctors in the network? Is each prescription on the plan’s formulary, the list of drugs it covers?
- Enrolling you. The broker submits the application so you do not have to work through carrier forms alone.
- Following up. Questions about a bill, a denied claim or a plan that no longer fits next year.
This is not only good practice. Federal rules require it. CMS, the federal agency that runs Medicare, requires agents and brokers to go over a set list of items with you before the enrollment process begins. The list covers the plan type you want, whether your current providers and pharmacy are in network, whether your prescriptions are on the formulary, and your needs for hearing, dental, vision, medical equipment or physical therapy.
What brokers are required to know and do
Brokers cannot simply start selling. CMS says agents and brokers must be licensed in the state where they do business, complete annual training and testing, and follow Medicare marketing rules. Breaking those rules can cost them their state license and lead plans to end their contracts. The CMS 2026 compensation memo adds that organizations must train and test every agent and broker each year on Medicare Parts A, B, C and D, with a passing score of 85% or higher.
Medicare broker vs. agent: does the difference matter?
In everyday conversation the two words overlap. MedPAC, the independent agency that advises Congress on Medicare, describes agents as licensed individuals who enroll people into insurance products and brokers as intermediaries between potential enrollees and insurance companies. It also notes that both are compensated by insurers.
So the legal label is less useful than a practical question: how many carriers can this person actually enroll me with?
Captive or single-carrier agent Independent broker Plans you can see One company’s plans Plans from multiple carriers Who pays them That one insurer Insurers, through commissions What you pay them Nothing Nothing Best for Someone who has already decided on one company Someone who wants plans compared side by sideThe gap is real. A 2021 Commonwealth Fund report found that agents are not required to represent every available plan, and that three large online plan-selection tools showed on average only 43.3% of Medicare Advantage plans and 64.7% of Part D plans in the markets studied. A broker who works across many carriers in your county is built to show you a wider field than a single company’s site or a generic online tool.
Are Medicare brokers free?
Yes, to you. NCOA, the National Council on Aging, states that a broker or agent cannot ask you for payment: there is no broker’s fee, and the plan bills you directly. Your plan premium is the same whether you enroll through a broker or on your own.
The insurer pays the broker instead. Here is how the pay works for each plan type.
Medigap
Medigap commissions are not set by federal rule. MedPAC explains that agent actions are governed by state law and that commissions are typically a percentage of the annual premium: about 20% for initial enrollment and 10% for each following year. On the 2023 average Medigap premium of $2,604, that works out to roughly $521 in the first year and $260 in renewal years.
Medicare Advantage and Part D
For these plans, CMS sets a ceiling. Under federal regulation, initial compensation to an independent agent or broker must be at or below fair market value, and renewal compensation is capped at 50% of that amount. For 2026, CMS’s memo sets the national maximum at $474 initial and $237 renewal for Medicare Advantage, and $114 initial and $57 renewal for stand-alone Part D, with higher amounts in some states and territories. CMS updates these figures each plan year, so check the CMS compensation page for the current table.

CMS also explains the rhythm: a broker generally receives an initial payment in the first year and half as much for later years if you stay enrolled. That is why a broker who looks after you year after year has a reason to keep your plan working for you.
Carriers may also pay brokers other forms of compensation, such as bonuses and payments for sales of other products. The practical protection for you is the federal rule that compensation must be set to encourage enrolling people in the plan intended to best meet their health care needs.
What a broker cannot do
Knowing the rules helps you spot a good professional quickly. According to NCOA, a broker or agent cannot:
- Come to your home uninvited.
- Offer cash or gifts worth more than $15 to join a plan.
- Sell you a non-Medicare product during a Medicare sales pitch.
- Pressure you to enroll in a specific plan.
- Ask for payment.
- Ask for the names and numbers of your friends and family.
A careful broker will not come near any of these, and you can read the full list at NCOA. If someone does, you can end the conversation and report it through Colorado’s Senior Medicare Patrol, described below.
Do you need a Medicare broker?
No, you can enroll yourself through Medicare. MedPAC lists several sources of help for beneficiaries: agents and brokers, Medicare’s Plan Finder, and State Health Insurance Assistance Programs, or SHIPs. SHIP counselors are federally funded, work through state programs and receive no compensation from insurers.
In Colorado, SHIP sits within the Division of Insurance and offers free, unbiased and individualized information through local partner locations. The same page describes the Senior Medicare Patrol, which helps people prevent, detect and report health care fraud and abuse. If you are also comparing carriers for other kinds of coverage, such as Aetna and Cigna for mental health care, it helps to have one person who sees the whole picture.
A broker makes the most sense when:
- You are turning 65 and facing your first plan choice, where a wrong pick can follow you for a year or more.
- You take several prescriptions, or see specialists you want to keep.
- You are weighing Medicare Advantage against Original Medicare with a Medigap plan, and want both options priced side by side. Our guide to Medicare Advantage vs. Medigap lays out the trade-offs.
- You want one person to call when a claim is denied or your plan changes next year.
- You would rather not spend a weekend on carrier websites.
A worked example: turning 65 in Castle Pines
Say you are 64, live in Castle Pines, take three regular prescriptions, and see a cardiologist in Denver you want to keep. Going alone, you might open a plan finder tool, enter your drugs and get a ranked list. The list will not tell you that your cardiologist’s group dropped out of one plan’s network, or that a drug moves to a higher tier on another.
With a broker, the conversation follows the CMS list: your preferred plan type, your doctors, your pharmacy, your formulary, and any hearing, dental or vision needs. The broker then compares options from multiple carriers, shows you the premium and the out-of-pocket exposure for each, and enrolls you in the one you pick. You can try our Medicare Cost Calculator beforehand to see what Medicare might cost you, and our Enrollment Timeline to see when each window opens.
Our point of view
We are an independent brokerage, and we think the best Medicare help has three parts: it compares across carriers, it is local, and it does not end on enrollment day.
Comparing across carriers matters because no single company has the best plan for every person. Local matters because networks are built county by county, and a plan that looks great on paper may not include the doctors and pharmacy you use in Castle Pines, Castle Rock, Parker or Denver.
Staying involved matters most. Plans change every year, health changes, and claims sometimes go wrong. Our service includes claims assistance, annual plan reviews, and help with appeals and grievances, so you have someone to call after you enroll. Your cost for all of this is nothing, because carriers pay us when you enroll.
Zach
How we help at Simply Insurance
We are a licensed independent brokerage serving Castle Pines and the rest of Colorado. We help with Medicare planning, Medicare Advantage consultations, Plan G and Plan N Medigap quotes, Part D prescription drug plans, annual enrollment, appeals and grievances, and Social Security planning. We also help families with individual health, dental, accident and critical illness coverage.

If you want to see your options side by side, start on our services page or go straight to Medicare planning. Prefer to read first? Our Medicare Guide answers common questions in plain language, and our Medicare Eligibility Calculator shows when you qualify. Living elsewhere in the metro area? We also serve readers through our Denver, Centennial and Parker pages.
FAQ
Are Medicare brokers really free?
Yes. You never pay a broker’s fee, and the plan bills you its normal premium whether or not you use a broker. Insurers pay the broker a commission, and for Medicare Advantage and Part D plans, CMS sets the maximum.
What is the difference between a Medicare broker and a Medicare agent?
MedPAC describes agents as licensed individuals who enroll people in insurance products and brokers as intermediaries between consumers and insurers. In practice, ask how many carriers the person can enroll you with. An independent broker can compare plans from many companies.
Do I need a Medicare broker to enroll?
No, but it helps if you are new to Medicare or have complex drug or doctor needs. A broker checks your doctors, pharmacy and prescriptions against each plan and handles the application. Free counseling is also available through Colorado SHIP.
Does using a broker change what my plan costs?
No. Your premium and benefits are set by the plan, not by who enrolls you. The broker’s commission is paid by the insurer, and renewal compensation is lower than the first-year payment under CMS rules.
When should I talk to a broker?
Ideally a few months before you turn 65, or before the annual enrollment period each fall if you want to review your current plan. Check Medicare.gov and our enrollment timeline for the current windows.
Sources
- CMS: Agent and Broker Training and Testing Guidelines, CY 2025
- CMS: Agent Broker Compensation
- CMS: Agent/broker compensation and training memo, CY 2026
- MedPAC: Background on Medicare insurance agents, March 2025
- MedPAC: Medicare agents and payment adequacy, March 2025
- Commonwealth Fund: How Agents Influence Medicare Beneficiaries’ Plan Choices, 2021
- NCOA: Common Questions and Answers for Caregivers About Medicare Open Enrollment
- Colorado Division of Insurance: Senior Health Care and Medicare
